Three new studies describe concrete actions to prevent or reverse abrupt ecological shifts
From coral reefs to prairie grasslands, some of the world’s most iconic habitats are susceptible to sudden collapse due to seemingly minor events. A classic example: the decimation of kelp forests when a decline of otter predation unleashes urchin population explosions. Three studies published in the Nov. 24 special issue of Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society—Biological Science hold the promise of helping resource managers predict, avoid, and reverse the tipping points that lead to degraded habitats, economic losses, and social upheaval.
The studies are the initial findings of the Ocean Tipping Points Project, an international research collaboration.
“In a sea of tipping points, identifying, anticipating, and reacting to sudden ecosystem changes will be critical as we seek to maintain the delivery of the goods and services from our oceans,” says co-author Phil Levin, a fisheries biologist at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
In the first study, scientists from the Center for Ocean Solutions at Stanford University and the Environmental Defense Fund evaluated 51 case studies around the globe. They found that successful management of systems with known tipping points depends strongly on three factors: consistent monitoring, explicit incorporation of tipping points data into management actions, and management at small geographic scales. The authors conclude that areas of approximately 6,500 mi2 (17,000 km2, roughly twice the area of Yellowstone National Park) or less are easier to understand, monitor, and manage at the local scale.
"Tipping points are important and potentially critical for effective resource management, and managers who use tipping points science are achieving positive results for virtually every kind of ecosystem,” says co-author Ashley Erickson, JD, Policy and Education Manager with the Center for Ocean Solutions. “The findings of our study can help resource managers focus and prioritize their efforts."
The second study, authored by researchers from NOAA and the University of Hamburg, provides additional guidance for marine managers on how to incorporate the risk of reaching a tipping point into current ecosystem-based management frameworks. The authors demonstrate how to adapt NOAA’s widely used Integrated Ecosystem Assessment (IEA) framework for marine ecosystems where tipping points are a concern. This risk-analysis based approach helps managers determine the likelihood that an ecosystem will cross a threshold, and what the resulting socio-economic and environmental impacts might be.
In the third study, researchers from the Center for Ocean Solutions, Stockholm Resilience Centre, University of Hawai`i, NOAA, and the Scripps Institute of Oceanography used a comprehensive spatial dataset to identify three distinct regimes of Hawaiian Archipelago reef ecosystems: hard corals, turf algae, or macroalgae. Though some algal cover is natural in the Hawaiian Archipelago, algae-dominated reefs are often the degraded remains of once-diverse coral communities. More than half of Hawai`i’s reefs are currently in the algae-dominated regimes, thanks to multiple stressors including overfishing and nutrient pollution.
In the absence of predators, sea urchin populations can grow out of control and eat all of the kelp in an ecosystem, creating ‘urchin barrens’ that result in a regime shift. Photo Credit: Ronald H. McPeak, UCSB Digital Commons, UC Regents.
“To safeguard Hawai`i’s coral reefs, we need to keep herbivore populations healthy and reduce other human stressors, such as land run-off, that encourage the growth of algae,” states lead author Jean-Baptiste Jouffray of the Stockholm Resilience Centre. “By identifying tipping points this study offers a promising avenue to provide tangible targets for just how much those stressors need to be reduced to avoid regime shifts in healthy reefs and restore those already in decline. Such information is critical for managers seeking to protect the reefs and the ecosystem services they can generate.”
The Ocean Tipping Points Project is a collaboration of the Center for Ocean Solutions, the National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, NOAA, the Environmental Defense Fund, California Polytechnic State University, and others. The effort is documenting ecological thresholds worldwide and working closely with local stakeholders and policymakers to develop management strategies to mitigate them. Funding is provided by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation, NOAA’s Coral Reef Conservation Program, and others.
More information on the Ocean Tipping Points Project: http://oceantippingpoints.org
Carrie Kappel, (805) 893-7467 or kappel [at] nceas.ucsb.edu
Kristen Weiss, (805) 279-1475 or kristenw [at] stanford.edu
Authors contact information
Assistant Professor in the School of Marine and Environmental Affairs
University of Washington
rpkelly [at] uw.edu
Policy and Education Manager
Center for Ocean Solutions
ashleye1 [at] stanford.edu
Program Manager, Ecosystem Science
NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center
Phil.levin [at] noaa.gov
Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University
jean-baptiste.jouffray [at] su.se
Mobile: +33.618.104.22.168 (UTC+01:00)